欢迎访问《图学学报》 分享到:

图学学报

• 智能设计与数字化设计 • 上一篇    下一篇

产品设计评价中专家权重动态赋权方法及应用

  

  1. 湖北工业大学工业设计学院,湖北 武汉 430068
  • 出版日期:2019-02-28 发布日期:2019-02-27
  • 基金资助:
    教育部人文社会科学研究规划基金项目(18YJAZH048);湖北省教育厅教研基金项目(2016286)

Dynamic Allocation of Weights to Experts for Evaluation of  Product Design and Its Application

  1. School of Industrial Design, Hubei University of Technology, Wuhan Hubei 430068, China
  • Online:2019-02-28 Published:2019-02-27

摘要: 为提高产品设计评价结果的可靠性,构建了一种基于群体共识度和聚类分析的专 家权重动态赋权流程。引入群体共识度和贴近度模型来判断、识别及排除差异性较大的专家评 价结果,促进群体评价达到共识度阈值要求;利用系统聚类算法演绎不同评价准则下专家群体 的归类情况,确定类容量大小,进行动态赋权;最后通过加权计算获得综合评价结果,为设计 决策提供评价参考。以车用智能警示牌概念方案的设计评价为例,验证了其可行性和有效性, 并进行不同赋权方法下综合评价结果的对比研究。结果表明,该方法能够客观、真实地表征专 家个体对不同评价对象的认知程度,其综合评价结果在可靠性上优于平均赋权方法和静态赋权 方法,具有一定的实用价值。

关键词: 工业设计, 动态赋权, 共识度, 聚类分析, 设计评价

Abstract: In order to evaluate product design more reliably, a process for dynamic allocation of weights to experts is proposed. The group consensus model is introduced to measure the degree of difference between expert opinions. The level of similarity is used to detect and eliminate very distinct expert opinions, thereby allowing a consensus to be reached more easily and efficiently. Weights of expert opinions are determined dynamically using the clustering algorithm to sort out the quality of various product designs. The proposed method is applied to the real-world intelligent warning sign of vehicle. Results demonstrate the ability of the proposed method to capture the difference between expert opinions effectively, allocate weights to expert opinions dynamically and evaluate the product more reliably. Finally, the proposed method is compared with other competing methods to prove its superiority, yielding insights into the evaluation of product design.

Key words: industrial design, dynamic weights, coefficient of consensus, cluster analysis, design evaluation